Skip to main content

BOWLS

Blue Buffalo Bowl

Feelin' a lil' Blue? Then this finger-lickin' Buffalo Chicken bowl's for you! Topped with diced-up panko-crusted chicken tenders tossed in our tangy, homemade Buffalo sauce, and crowned with melted Blue Jack cheese, all drizzled with Ranch. No bowls about it!

MPD Bowl

If it's beef you're craving, we've got just the bowl to satisfy your meat tooth! Topped with our premium, slow roasted beef brisket, sweet caramelized onions, and sliced horseradish White Cheddar cheese, all smothered in our heavenly holy aioli. A bowl-load of flavor with every bite!

Brooklyn Porkster Bowl

Why eat a pig in a blanket when you can have a Porkster in a bowl? Topped with sliced Cheddar, caramelized onions, crunchy dill pickles, and housemade BBQ pulled pork all doused with Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ sauce. Sweet bowls of fire!

Times Square Pizza Bowl

Square peg in a round hole? More like Times Square Pizza in a round bowl! Topped with melted Mozzarella, roasted pepperoni, housemade marinara sauce and fresh basil. It's unbelieve-a-bowl!

Truffle Shuffle Bowl

Shroom lovers rejoice! We're bringing the Midtown magic to the Truffle Shuffle bowl! Topped with garlic and herb-roasted mushrooms, caramelized onions, and melted Mozzarella and Swiss cheese, all drizzled with our exquisite truffle aioli. Bowl Appetit!

MELTS

WALL STREET GRINDER

What do you get when you stuff a waffled melt with American cheese, empire waffle fries, Applewood smoked bacon, caramelized onions, a scrambled egg and artisanal mayo? A stock-soaring investment in foodie delight.

BROADWAY CLASSIC

American and Swiss cheese, melted in matrimony with our housemade garlic butter, are pressed between toasted sourdough for a classic twist that’ll have you oozing with delight. Taste-tested, Brie-approved... but your Mama may disagree!

Vegetarian

BLUE BUFFALO

Tender, panko-crusted chicken strips tossed in our tangy housemade Buffalo sauce and smothered in good ol’ American cheese. Add our melty blue-jack cheese and artisanal mayo and you’ve got yourself all the flavor of some old-fashioned wings - finger lickin’ good, without the mess.

FIFTH AVENUE

Melted Muenster and American cheeses, our juicy panko fried chicken tenders tossed in a hot sriracha and fire-roasted pepper jam, topped with crispy bacon and served on country loaf, garnished with caramelized garlic cloves.

MANHATTAN GRILLED MAC & CHEESE

It’s the melt comfort food dreams are made of. Ooey-gooey Cavatappi mac & cheese bathed in creamy American cheese and waffled to perfection. Do double duty on crushing those cravings.

Vegetarian

VILLAGE VEGAN

A vegan-friendly, Mama approved melt, chock full of vegan mozzarella, a savory alternative meat crumble, topped with sweet caramelized onions and served with our vegan mushroom bisque.

Vegan

MIDTOWN TRUFFLE SHUFFLE

This creation will have shroom-lovers melting for more with our garlic and herb-roasted mushrooms, melted mozzarella, caramelized onions and savory Swiss cheese. A drizzle of our truffle aioli gives this melt all the shuffle it needs.

Vegetarian

TIME SQUARE PIZZA MELT

The ball drops for this pizzarific melt, filled with roasted pepperoni, housemade marinara sauce, and smothered in classic mozzarella cheese. Combined with fresh basil and a buttery garlic spread on our waffled country loaf, it’s amore all around.

BROOKLYN PORKSTER

This lil’ piggy went to NYGC. Brooklyn’s finest American cheese, caramelized onions, crunchy dill pickles and Sweet Baby Ray’s® BBQ sauce all top our housemade BBQ pulled pork. So tender and tangy, it’s tantalizing.

SOHO SWEET CHEESE

Sweet dreams are made of brie, especially when it’s fine, French and creamy. It’s paired with sweet caramelized onions, crunchy Applewood smoked bacon, between two slices of oatmeal wheat bread and drizzled with a very berry Aioli that’ll make you shout OUI!

MEAT PACKING DISTRICT (MPD)

Where’s the (slow-roasted, premium) beef? This melt is packin’ major meat and is waffled to perfection with nose-punchin’ horseradish white cheddar cheese, American cheese, sweet caramelized onions and finger lickin’ holey aioli.

Fries

SWEET POTATO WAFFLE FRIES

These sweet potato darlings come paired with our world-famous marshmallow dipping sauce. Once you dip these pretty little things, you won’t be able to stop. Extra napkins required.

Vegan, Gluten Free

HOT PORK SUNDAE

This hot pork sundae pairs our tender and juicy slow-roasted BBQ pulled pork with our Empire Waffle Fries, melted American cheese, a heaping ladle of hearty gravy, a hint of our Cajun seasoning and garnished with chives.

EMPIRE WAFFLE FRIES

Some saw New York is the best city on Earth, and we say that our Empire Waffle Fries stand taller than the rest with flavor and the perfect crisp-to-fluffiness ratio.

Vegan, Gluten Free

VEGAN POUTINE

Our irresistible waffle fries are cozied up under melted vegan mozzarella, so creamy you’d swear it was the real thing! A sprinkling of chives and a side of our housemade onion-mushroom gravy make this poutine complete.

Vegan

PIZZA FRIES

It’s a pizza-lovers dream as our Empire Waffle Fries come served up smothered in our housemade marinara sauce, melted mozzarella cheese, and topped with a crumbling of pepperoni, cheese and fresh basil.

Gluten Free

NEW YORK FRIES

Our famous golden waffle fries are tossed in a housemade chili glaze topped with cheddar cheese, crispy Applewood smoked bacon bits, sprinkled with chives and lusted after by hungry diners from Times Square to the Battery Tunnel.

Gluten Free

DISCO FRIES (POUTINE)

Clear the dance floor, this Canadian classic is taking center stage. Our waffle fries are crispy on the outside, soft on the inside, smothered in authentic cheese curd, classic housemade brown gravy, then garnished with chives. Oh, Canada!

TRUFFLE FRIES

Elevate your meal with your hand-cut, crispy waffle fries bathed in authentic melted cheese curds drizzled with the finest truffle aioli and sprinkled with chives.

Vegetarian, Gluten Free

GRAMERCY GARLIC CHEESE FRIES

This flavor taxi’s headin’ to Gramercy for our famous waffle fries, tossed delicately in our fingerlickin’ housemade garlic aioli, topped with creamy melted cheddar and a sprinklin’ of chives.

Vegetarian, Gluten Free

YANKEE FRIES

A purely-genius pairing of crispy fries, housemade buffalo sauce, creamy ranch, melted cheddar, fire-roasted jalepeños pickled in-house and chives. Craving protein? Ask for diced chicken tenders and make this Yankee Doodle even more dandy.

Vegetarian, Gluten Free

MUNCHIES

MAC & CHEESE

Cavatappi macaroni as ooey gooey and cheesy as the flavor gods intended, finished off with a sprinkle of chives.

Vegetarian

BACON LOLLIPOPS

Applewood smoked bacon smothered in our maple glaze and skewered for your delight.

Gluten Free

MIDTOWN MUSHROOM BISQUE

Plump, juicy shrooms in a finger-lickin’ creamy bowl of yum. A vegan delight worth dipping your melt into.

Vegan

TOMATO BASIL BISQUE

No melt would be complete without our world-famous, housemade, ultra creamy tomato-basil bisque. Get your dunk on!

Vegetarian

BACON-DOG LOLLIPOPS

Bacon-wrapped juicy beef franks dipped in Maple glaze, all on a stick. You're welcome.

Gluten Free

CHICKEN TENDERS BOAT

Bon Voyage! This boat is headed to flavor town complete with four strips of the finest panko-crusted boneless chicken and served with our housemade sweet chili aioli so you can take these babies for a fiery sweet dip.

Kids

KIDS GRILLED CHEESE

Not Your Mother's Grilled Cheese? Well we won't tell if you won't! A grilled cheese unlike any other, we have a kid’s melt that’ll have you oozing with delight while serving up your little one’s happy belly!

KIDS MAC & CHEESE

Ooey, gooey and cheesy, there’s a reason kids love macaroni and cheese! And after one heart-warming scoop into their mouth, we're sure they'll love ours even more! But don't worry...you can thank us later :) 

KIDS CHICKEN TENDERS

If our kid-approved melt ain't enough to win their love, we've got just the tender thing! A real crowd pleaser, our Chicken Tenders get their name from all-natural, whole white meat we so proudly use. This tasty dish is served with our famous golden waffle fries. 

DESSERTS

HELL’S KITCHEN SWEET BAKE

Hell?! More like heaven! Baked fresh in-house, our artisan bread creation is made with velvety housemade custard, drizzled with creamy marshmallow and mixed berry sauces, and topped with white chocolate morsels. You can share, but you won’t want to.

SUGAR HILL SWEET BAKE

This exquisite sweet bake is made with our velvety scratch-made hazelnut-chocolate custard, loaded with crushed oreos, white chocolate, baked to perfection, then drizzled with a kiss of Nutella and marshmallow sauces, all topped with crushed Oreo pieces for that extra sweet crunch. Ain’t no sugar hill high enough to keep us from gettin’ to you, babe.

speaking of

CHEESE

“We have eaten here so many times, I'm flabbergasted that I haven't written a review of just how much I love this place. I'm particular about giving out 5 stars on Yelp. The recipient has to have consistent, excellent customer service, better than good food, and a certain magical quality like that of Julia Child riding a unicorn. New York Grilled Cheese has this magic.”

ROB C.

“The best!! I love coming here! Its a bit of a drive from Miami but its absolutely worth it! The employees are great, the food is delicious and the area is great. No complaints from my end. I love going on dates here with my husband“

ELISE B.

“OMG we have been twice in the past week. Different sandwiches both times. I am currently planning our next visit now. So many choices so little time!“

Gena G.

“We have eaten here so many times, I'm flabbergasted that I haven't written a review of just how much I love this place. I'm particular about giving out 5 stars on Yelp. The recipient has to have consistent, excellent customer service, better than good food, and a certain magical quality like that of Julia Child riding a unicorn. New York Grilled Cheese has this magic.”

Kara K.

“I left this place in physical pain because I could NOT. STOP. EATING! Maybe we over ordered but everything was too good. We started with the bacon lollipops. What's not to love about crispy bacon on a stick coated in sweet maple glaze? The mac and cheese was great but if I had to cut one thing out it would have been that but only because I needed more room for delicious grilled cheese.”

Scotty C.

see our

full menu

HANDCRAFTED WITH ONLY THE FINEST INGREDIENTS.